Judge Halts School Secrecy Policy
If you’re anything like me, you find yourself continually scratching your head, trying to understand how our State can be so determined to force schools to keep secrets from parents about their own children’s mental health and social‑emotional well-being. It’s astonishing.
Under the banner of the Law Against Discrimination, state officials are insisting parents have no right to this information unless a child explicitly consents—even as young as six years old. Think about that. The State is asserting that a first grader should have the unilateral authority to withhold critical information from their parents.
Let me explain why this is clearly wrong and unacceptable. I will try to do it on a first-grade level since our state officials believe that’s the level of maturity you need to understand the complexity of this issue.
“A boy is a boy, and a girl is a girl. If a boy thinks that he is a girl, or if a girl thinks that she is a boy, we should tell their mom and dad.”
That’s it. Parents should not be cut out of the most sensitive conversations about their child’s well‑being.
Recently, Attorney Ron Berutti was successful in getting Monmouth County Assignment Judge Marc C. Lemieux to issue a preliminary injunction against Monmouth Regional High School’s Policy 5145.7—a policy modeled directly after the well-known 5756.
This ruling means that Monmouth Regional High School may no longer keep information about a student’s gender identity secret from parents. For that district, the State’s attempt to impose secrecy has been halted.
But let me be clear: the legal battles are not over. More districts will face litigation as parents continue to challenge policies that cut them out of critical decisions involving their children. Efforts are already underway to intervene in these cases so that future rulings apply statewide, ensuring that every school in New Jersey respects the fundamental rights of parents.
This is a significant step—but it is only the beginning.
I must say, dealing with the broader issue of transgender identity is never without its amusing inconsistencies, especially as proponents struggle to defend positions that simply don’t align with reality.
Take this example.
When we warn legislators that gender‑transition procedures performed on minors can lead to sterilization, transgender activists in the committee room often smirk, giggle, and shake their heads, signaling to lawmakers that our concerns are unfounded—that these interventions carry no such risks.
Yet just last week, on September 17, in the Assembly Financial Institutions and Insurance Committee, this very same activist group testified in favor of Assembly Bill 2281, which would require Medicaid to cover fertility preservation services—freezing eggs, sperm, embryos, or gonadal tissue—before someone begins “gender‑affirming hormone therapy” or other surgeries, explicitly because a person’s reproductive potential may be impaired.
In other words, they deny the risk in one hearing and then affirm it in another when seeking additional funding. You can’t make this stuff up!
This is exactly the kind of contradiction that exposes how unstable and politically driven these policies have become. Parents deserve honesty. Legislators deserve clarity. And children deserve better than a system built on shifting narratives.


